Doom 3 can still look really good even by today’s standards. Recently played Doom 3 to the end on a Dell laptop with a 5650 GPU and it ran silky smooth at 1920 x 1080 ultra settings maxed out AA.
Game was made more fearsome and ultra scary by the exclusion of the flashlight, however yes. Any sane and sensible marine would tape a flashlight to his gun or armour or something… Was a bit of a blunder by ID software however it was most certainly an intentional one as with the tape mod Doom 3 was nowhere near as scary…
ID software hit the sweet spot with Doom 3, although as mentioned, game did get repetitive towards the end. And it did become a little predictable, monsters would drop through the ceiling or jump from behind a door.
Still for its time, it was cutting edge visuals, and had excellent feel to the guns.
Only Half life 2 was IMO the better game released around the same time, however Doom 3 was still one of ID softwares greatest games to date.
Rage sadly was a bit rubbish, I was quite shocked when I played Bulletstorm and Rage recently and Rage ran like turd on my PC yet Bulletstorm was fluid and smooth on the same hardware and looked better IMO and a heck of a lot more fun as well…
If no one was played Doom 3 then provided its cheap enough, you’ll be in a for a bit of scary treat.. Not to everyone’s taste, but decidedly good game nonetheless.