I use a colormunki photo for monitor and printer profiling for paper my match is spot on every time the x-rite i1 display pro is a better monitor calibrator for sure as the munki is a low end spectrophotometer but never had a mismatch with the colormuki for paper profiles.
We have all been there with wasted paper and ink over years no more
Also as said above by Greebo if you use an older spyder with alternate software such as DisplayCal you will be surprised.
Even the x-rite i1 display pro is held back by it's own software.