I'm not sure what you're having difficulty understanding here /sigh. You claimed that he was breathing on his own but needed an oxygen tank to breath, they are mutually exclusive, you cannot be capable of breathing on your own AND require assistance to breath because you can't breathe on your own.
I was simply pointing out that one of those statements must be false (due to the mutual exclusivity).
no, you just misread a post... I even quoted it for you above but you still don't get it...
do you understand that if you're dehydrated you can be said to "need water"?
that doesn't imply you're currently receiving water
so I made a statement that he was breathing on his own i.e. without support... but needs oxygen, it doesn't imply he's currently receiving oxygen especially when the next words are "and the hospital won't allow it"
you've just misread a post (your mistake was that you decided that "needs oxygen" must imply he's receiving oxygen) and when you quoted it you chose to cut out the bit that actually puts it in context (which you've done a second time above)
Last edited: