US police thread

Status
Not open for further replies.
Man of Honour
Joined
5 Dec 2003
Posts
20,999
Location
Just to the left of my PC
All these armchair IT wizards saying “omfg how do you mistake a gun for a taser, incompetent idiots!?“ need to just pipe down. The hardest decision they have to make every day is whether to have soy or almond milk with their coffee.

If someone trained with and routinely carrying both a gun and a taser can mistake one for the other then one of those objects is designed incorrectly, their training is inadequate or they aren't at a high enough level of competence. Or a combination of the above. When the consequences of a mistake are a matter of life and death, adequate steps should be constantly in place to prevent that mistake.

They're often not, though. I watch a Youtube channel ("Plainly Difficult") that has short documentaries on various failures, often fatal and sometimes disastrous. Reactor meltdowns, criticality events, dam failures, etc. The prevailing theme is that adequate steps were not taken.
 
Soldato
Joined
25 Oct 2004
Posts
8,883
Location
Sunny Torbaydos
Mistakes do happen, were only human. Even the most highly trained SAS commandos makes mistakes from time to time.

This is nothing more than an accidental discharge of a firearm, it wasn't intended, it wasn't "police brutality" yada yada yada and it certainly wasn't white cop racist shootin up the hood.
 
Soldato
Joined
10 May 2012
Posts
10,062
Location
Leeds
Oh no! Some of them "Tugged at barricades"!!!

Better get in a bunker.

I think deep down you know Trump was advised by Secret Service to go to the bunker due to their perception of a security threat based on intelligence, it's cool though I know you're just poking fun at someone you don't like
 
Man of Honour
Joined
13 Oct 2006
Posts
91,163
I more rural areas of the UK fire arms units often pull double duty as traffic duties so that they can be kept mobile to cut down on response times when major police stations can be 30-40miles apart.
Or at least that is my understanding, I know there is a few serving officers on the board eho may be able to correct me.

I don't know the truth of it but I've seen armed response units turning up to stuff in rural Dorset/Somerset a fair bit which is often run of the mill stuff.
 
Soldato
Joined
13 Apr 2013
Posts
12,412
Location
La France
F111s were retired in the late 90s. Sorry - plane nerd here.

RAF Alconbury early 1980s. Right when CND were protesting outside all the USAF bases that were believed to have nuclear weapons deployed their.

My late father and I both had base passes of RAF Alconbury Rod & Gun Club having met up with some USAF clay shooters at RAF Chicksands previously and been invited to shoot with them. Now, my late father thought he knew the way from gate to sleet range and couldn’t be persuaded that he’d gotten us lost. Queue our world being suddenly filled with blue lights, MP trucks and MPs pointing M16s at us we where approaching the set of covered revetments where the F111s on ready status were parked.

A short explanation and showing of our passes followed by multiple apologies later, we were escorted to the sleet range. Next time we went there, there were “Skeet Range >” signs at every turn between gate and range, so I guess we weren’t the only lost Brits that weekend.
 
Soldato
Joined
3 Oct 2007
Posts
12,091
Location
London, UK
No point making a comparison really. On one hand you have a land that may as well be an episode of Cops set in the Shire, and the other being set in Mordor just to point out the typical levels of danger each could face on a daily.

I would hazard to say a UK police officer would be a terrible police officer in US and could put both themselfs and their colleagues lives at risk simply by being unaware of just how much danger they can face.

The USA also have a firearms team, they'll called the SWAT they'll go out on clear intelligence and usually apprehend people dead or alive if they can safetly do so. They don't go out to interact with the public.

That's not true because I game online with a cop and he is on their SWAT team and a regular cop. Admittedly he doesn't live in a city but more a town.
 
Associate
Joined
15 May 2004
Posts
489
That's not true because I game online with a cop and he is on their SWAT team and a regular cop. Admittedly he doesn't live in a city but more a town.
Just checked and you are correct. They could be performing normal duties, however not all police officers are SWAT members, and nor should they have to be. They are called up to enlist themselfs in very dangerous situations that could go horribly wrong and human error can still happen even to the most highly trained.
 
Soldato
Joined
12 Oct 2006
Posts
10,234
Location
Tatooine
I’ll see your cops with MP5s and raise you USAF Security Forces with M16s. Don’t get lost on USAF bases.

Turns out they take unauthorised people getting near active F111 flight lines very seriously.
That was back in early 2000's late 1990's and just a personal experience after a local shooting. They did have assault rilfes not sure what type. I remember them having brown or wooden barrels.

G36'S and Glocks are standard issues these days.
 
Soldato
Joined
15 Aug 2005
Posts
22,977
Location
Glasgow
I more rural areas of the UK fire arms units often pull double duty as traffic duties so that they can be kept mobile to cut down on response times when major police stations can be 30-40miles apart.
Or at least that is my understanding, I know there is a few serving officers on the board eho may be able to correct me.

A few of forces have combined their Roads Policing and Firearms teams, and even in the ones that haven't it's normal for ARVs to get involved in roads policing given they're out driving around anyway, as most matters can be dealt with at the roadside fairly easily or handed over to another unit.

Up here there was a bit of resistance when Police Scotland said that their ARV officers would routinely carry their firearms (rather than being secured in the vehicle) and would engage in non-firearms duties. People wanted the weapons hidden away and the officers off the streets until needed. That was until Police Scotland started to document some of the non-firearms jobs those officers were involved in, including administering emergency medical care to people, using defibs on people suffering heart attacks etc. The critics went strangely silent after that.
 
Man of Honour
Joined
24 Sep 2005
Posts
35,492
If someone trained with and routinely carrying both a gun and a taser can mistake one for the other then one of those objects is designed incorrectly, their training is inadequate or they aren't at a high enough level of competence. Or a combination of the above.
Perfectly put.

Training, recruitment and design should be adequate enough (knowing the foreseeable consequences) that instances such as this should not happen.
 
Soldato
Joined
17 Jul 2007
Posts
24,529
Location
Solihull-Florida
Being reported she's resigned


And the police chief resigned and Mayor Mike Elliott fired the city manager for wanting due process.

So now they have no one in charge of the police. Nearly 300 have gone or on leave.
That city is about to crash and burn.

People who have money will leave asap.

"Wright then allegedly pulled a black handgun "with silver trim out from either his right waistband or his right coat pocket," pointed it at the woman and demanded the $820, the court documents say."

"Wright then allegedly choked the woman while trying to pull the cash out from under her bra, where she had tucked it away."

What a nice guy.
 
Soldato
Joined
3 Oct 2007
Posts
12,091
Location
London, UK
And the police chief resigned and Mayor Mike Elliott fired the city manager for wanting due process.

So now they have no one in charge of the police. Nearly 300 have gone or on leave.
That city is about to crash and burn.

People who have money will leave asap.

"Wright then allegedly pulled a black handgun "with silver trim out from either his right waistband or his right coat pocket," pointed it at the woman and demanded the $820, the court documents say."

"Wright then allegedly choked the woman while trying to pull the cash out from under her bra, where she had tucked it away."

What a nice guy.

I think everyone has heard way too many of your prophecies that failed to come true. Lets wait and see shall we.
 
Soldato
Joined
9 Jun 2005
Posts
4,694
Location
Wiltshire
"Wright then allegedly pulled a black handgun "with silver trim out from either his right waistband or his right coat pocket," pointed it at the woman and demanded the $820, the court documents say."

"Wright then allegedly choked the woman while trying to pull the cash out from under her bra, where she had tucked it away."

What a nice guy.


Shhhh, we're supposed to be sad that criminals get shot.
 
Soldato
Joined
16 Aug 2009
Posts
7,748
If someone trained with and routinely carrying both a gun and a taser can mistake one for the other then one of those objects is designed incorrectly, their training is inadequate or they aren't at a high enough level of competence. Or a combination of the above. When the consequences of a mistake are a matter of life and death, adequate steps should be constantly in place to prevent that mistake.

Part of the problem is that you have a society that openly permits handguns to be worn so police officers have to make a split second decision as to what they're going to do and I don't envy the pressure they must be under. Obviously that doesn't negate the fact that kneeling on someones neck for getting on for 10 minutes probably isn't going to end well but thats not a split second decision...
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top Bottom