Phanteks P500A + Arctic Freezer II 360 Compatibility (top mounting)

Associate
Joined
19 Jul 2010
Posts
914
Location
West Oxon
Been helping a friend recently with selecting parts and building a new system, he's gone for the Phanteks P500A case in white, and I recommended the Arctic Freezer II 360, although no RGB with that, we were fortunate enough to pick up a good pre-owned unit (Rev 2) and then some suitable RGB fans from the members market which also meant we had an RGB fan for the rear of the case, all for the same cost as a the coolers RRP.

So when putting it all together, turns out he encountered a little fitment/compatibility issue with trying to fit the radiator in the top of the case, again, just like the front of the case and the issue with the fans not fitting outside the chassis behind the front mesh panel, phanteks have half-assed the job of compatibility by penny pinching and skimping on materials by a few millimetres :rolleyes:


As you can see from these pictures, when placed in the top of the case and mounted as best as you can using the recessed mounting slots, the radiator hits up against the back of the case, and results in all but about 4 of the screw holes being misaligned :( (back of case is at the top of the right hand picture)

__________________


The issue, is this folded strengthening lip on the back panel, and the rivets that hold it in place, should have either spot welded the flat panel in place, or made it 5mm bigger, it's not like the Artic Freezer Radiator is monstrously over sized, just a poor job of ensuring compatibility no doubt driven by penny pinching.



The solution, as you can see here is to use some of the mesh holes and some small rubber washers between the radiator and the mesh, this allows all bar the tube end of the radiator to be fastened in securely. The top insert being flexible does indeed still fit, but those with OCD might wish to use suitable countersink head screws! (back of case is at the bottom of the picture)



It does raise the question, why didn't they just use a top panel with compatible size/spaced mesh holes stamped in it over the entire area, and simply supply rubber washers and do away with the contrived mounting positions, again, over complication in trying to create compatibility failing for the smallest and stupidest of reasons.
 
Soldato
Joined
10 Apr 2015
Posts
4,064
Location
Hungerford, UK, Earth
does look to be a design flaw. could you not have mounted the AIO to the front and moving the included fans to the top and rear especially since the front can handle a 420 radiator. Also might be worth sending Phanteks Customer Support an email, and include the pics or a link to this thread. They are generally pretty good at replying
 
Associate
OP
Joined
19 Jul 2010
Posts
914
Location
West Oxon
Hi,
Yeah, we could have fitted the cooler in the front as you suggested, but that would have messed with the whole look at the front with the 3x 140mm fans needing to be replaced by the 3x 120's of the radiator, not entirely sure how that would look, but as we did get him some RGB fans from the members market, at least they would have been illuminated.

We opted in the end not to go for the front mount for the following reasons
  • Difficulty (not impossible) in mounting tubes down due to positioning of PSU/lower compartment shroud/cover and a desire not to have a tubes up configuration.
  • Not wanting to take too much space away from the lower section if we did mount it tubes down because he wants to install some HDDs in that area.
  • A desire not to have to discard the 3x 140mm fans at the front, although as you said they could have been used in the top of the case as extract fans (already have a 120mm RGB fan for the rear)
  • Due to the planned vertical mounting of the GPU, I'm hoping to keep a cleaner flow of air from the lower 2 of the 140mm fans into the path of the GPU intake fans.
  • In the end, it wasn't the end of the world having to mount it like we did, it's just such a shame that they failed in such a small way for what is to my mind a no brainer, it just looks like someone tried to over think it.
 
Soldato
Joined
24 Feb 2013
Posts
4,134
Location
East Midlands
@Gunslinger

Would you get this issue with the 280 as well? When you say you used rubber washers, do you mean between the screw head and the mesh holes or actually between the radiator and bottom side of the mesh? If between bottom of mesh and radiator, how did you keep the rubber washers in place before mounting, glue?
 
Back
Top Bottom