sr4470 said:
Whoever said Eclipse throttle P2P 24\7, that wasnt intended, AFAIK its fixed now anyway.
Eclipse speeds have been all over the place recently, there was a case last week where P2P speeds and all encrypted traffic was limited to between about 20-50KB/s but they opened an outage on their Status page and seem to have it sorted now
HTTP speeds were also comparitively poor in the evenings at around 0.5-1.5mbps but that seems a bit better at peak times now as well, I got 3.5mbps yesterday and 2mbps just now, it varies from evening to evening but that's to be expected due to the contended nature of the service. Actual browsing during the low speeds was still pretty good and the speed never really dropped too much as after 1mbps there's not a lot of difference for surfing anyway.
BitTorrent is reasonable in the evenings, approx 2-3mbps speeds on a 4.5mbps line which looks like they've now got the shaping sorted properly as it varies on a well seeded torrent. Outside peak times most of the time it goes at my line speed.
Eclipse looks like your best bet if you do a lot of downloading and don't want to spend too much, they only limit the amount you download between 6pm - Midnight and the pricing seems pretty good. I'm on Option 3 at the moment and can download 40GB at peak times and unlimited outside those times for £24.99. I don't do anywhere near that though so might downgrade though.
I was looking at other ISPs when the throttle was in place incase they kept them 24/7 and didn't really see any other better packages, Zen looked quite pricey for the transfer limits, but I guess with ISPs (and everything else), "you get what you pay for" in most cases. If you want top speeds 24/7 with no usage limits you're going to need quite a large budget (how does £1600 a month for the BT Central bandwidth alone sound?
)