It's not fair that Katie must have shown her boobies to Spie and she smells. She's also a girl and everybody knows girls shouldn't go on computers. So she went to design college and probably made tea for all the boys all day. She's also done too many pixels because there's only so many pixels you should put in a logo.
haha thanks for putting it in perspective.
And if I must comment.....
katie's was the best logo imo, it's simple and informative, works well in a variety of situations. The only slight thing you could say is that it doesnt work as well on black as it did on white, but that's really quite minor, it was still the best I think.
I can't quite see what more there is to debate.