I follow Newcastle and have the associated dislike of Sunderland, however I will say this. I had and have a grudging admiration for him and his no nonsense approach and also it should be known that McCarthy had to sell players. I think with a decent budget, he will do a decent job.
The real spanner the works at that club is Bob Murray. As chairman, he has done nothing except build them a decent ground and I have to question what he hopes to achieve as Chairman ? He has no motivation, no passion, no personality and the get up and go of a dead sloth. He does not release funds, seek to increase funds or seemingly have any plans to progress the club.
He could do Sunderland a favour and step down or do Newcastle a favour and stay where he is.